Fenwick HS loses bid to overturn football state playoff loss in court

Fenwick's QB Jacob Keller is chased by Loyola's Anthony Romano during their football game Saturday Sept. 19 2015 in River Forest. | Tim Boyle  For the Sun-Times

A judge has rejected a suburban Chicago high school's argument that it deserves to play for the IL state championship because a referee's mistake cost it a playoff win.

Fenwick High School in Oak Park filed a motion in Cook County court asking for an emergency order to overturn the results of Saturday's Class 7A semifinal against Plainfield North High School.

Judge Kathleen Kennedy heard about 45 minutes of arguments from lawyers representing the IHSA and Fenwick High School before making her decision, according to the Chicago Tribune.

The matter landed in Cook County Circuit Court on Monday, as Fenwick filed an emergency petition, alleging the IHSA had trampled the school's contractual and due process rights by refusing to grant the school an appeal of the results of Fenwick's November 19 Class 7A state semifinal playoff loss to Plainfield North high school.

More news: Autumn Statement to boost housebuilding and wages

Officials mistakenly awarded Plainfield North an untimed down after calling a penalty on Fenwick for intentional grounding.

Following Judge Kennedy's decision, Fenwick representatives said they were "disheartened" by the judge's decision, but said they would not pursue any further legal action over the case. IHSA attorney David Bressler called Fenwick's attempt to get the game result overturned in court "absurd".

Fenwick wanted the court to intervene and declare them the victor, and allow them to play undefeated East Saint Louis in the Class 7A championship.

The IHSA said they "appreciate" the judge's decision to stay out of the matter, and let the IHSA "self-govern within the rules set by our member schools".

More news: NYC mayor: We'll sue if Trump makes Muslim registry

During two days eight games are played to decided eight IHSA football champions. Per Rule 3-3-4 in the 2016 NFHS Football Rules Book, the game should have concluded on the final play of regulation and the untimed down should not have been awarded. "Sometimes the law is not fair". In overtime Fenwick scored a touchdown first, kicking the extra point to go up 17-10, but Plainfield North scored on its ensuing possession and successfully completed the two-point conversion.

IHSA later issued a statement that stated, "there are no winners in this circumstance".

Update, 12:01 p.m. EST: The judge has ruled in favor of Plainfield North. "It is our job as an Association, Board of Directors and membership to look at our policies and rules to see if and how we might be able to prevent instances like this in the future". Judge Kennedy recognized the historic precedent that would have resulted if she had overturned the outcome of the game based on an officiating error.

Fenwick quarterback Jacob Keller later tweeted, "your sincerest apologies mean nothing, my boys WORKED for 5 months just to have everything we worked for taken away". On Monday morning, the IHSA board of directors determined that the association's bylaws did not allow a review of Fenwick's appeal.

More news: Vikings host Arizona at 12 Noon Sunday

Related:

  • It takes a 'Fantastic Beast' to unseat 'Doctor Strange' at box office

    Warner Bros' " Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them " debuted at first place this weekend in Northern America. The animated " Trolls " was a close third with $17.4 million, giving it a three-week take of $116.2 million.
    Here's why the moon looked so big on Monday night

    Here's why the moon looked so big on Monday night

    The December full moon is known as the Full Cold Moon because it coincides with the drop in temperatures that the winter brings. And the November lunar cycle orbits closer to the Earth than it has in decades, making the moon look enormous and luminous.

    Apple to discount products on Black Friday

    Hhregg , best black Friday deal for the iPad Pro dropped its price of $70 off, decreasing its price to only $729. There is no brand new iPad , which means retailers have room to play with discounts on the entire product lineup.
  • Federal court rules Wisconsin legislative maps unconstitutional

    Federal court rules Wisconsin legislative maps unconstitutional

    State lawyers argued the equation lacked any constitutional basis and there was no way a court could measure gerrymandering . Alongside the ruling, the judges also established a new precedent on measuring the severity of a gerrymandered map.
    University police officer shot in the head in Detroit

    University police officer shot in the head in Detroit

    The individual taken into custody has had previous contact with area law enforcement, and did not resist, according to police. This is the first shooting of a Wayne State officer in 36 years. "That shows you his leadership right there", Lockwood said.

    'Open mind' on quitting climate accords: Donald Trump

    China has its own reasons for cutting emissions, and it may try to burnish its reputation by assuming the U.S.'s leadership role. The coalition of countries meets once a year to review the Convention's progress and establish the rules of its implementation.
  • Wal-Mart kicks off Cyber Monday on Friday

    Wal-Mart kicks off Cyber Monday on Friday

    RetailNext believes that this Black Friday will not be the biggest shopping day of the year in terms of either traffic or sales. Stay tuned to SWR for more updates and news on the Black Friday 2016 Cheapest 4K TV Deals and Ultra HD TV Offers .
    Blues Beat Backes & Bruins 4-2

    Blues Beat Backes & Bruins 4-2

    RW David Pastrnak, who leads Boston with 10 goals, missed his third consecutive game with an undisclosed injury . There wasn't much action after that and the B's took their one-goal lead down the tunnel into first intermission.

    National Basketball Association roundup: Teague, Pacers win in overtime

    Larry Nance Jr. contributed 18 points, six rebounds and three assists off the bench. "We had nothing to lose there", Teague said. Carmelo Anthony matched his season high with 31 points and NY beat Atlanta for its fourth straight home victory.
  • Sensex rallies in midday trade, Nifty edges up; Lupin top gainer

    Sensex rallies in midday trade, Nifty edges up; Lupin top gainer

    Asian markets, Hong Kong's Hang Seng and Shanghai Composite Index were marginally down, while Japan's Nikkei was marginally up. The wider 51-scrip Nifty of the National Stock Exchange (NSE) was trading 155.05 points or 1.92 percent lower at 7,919.05.
    Santander Quits R3 Blockchain Consortium

    Santander Quits R3 Blockchain Consortium

    It is also rumoured that Morgan Stanley and National Bank of Australia could be the next companies to leave R3. According to sources of the new agency, the New York-based fintech startup has changed the terms of the deal.

    Volkswagen bets on new technology to bounce back from crisis

    He said regional managers would get " more local responsibility" to make decisions and meet local conditions. CEO Matthias Mueller said it was "the biggest reform package in the history of our core brand".

Comments

Latest news

Germany's Lufthansa cancels 912 flights in pilot strike
Lufthansa cancelled 900 flights on November 23 and 912 flights for November 24, which affected some 200,000 passengers. On Wednesday evening, the union said the walkouts would continue on Friday too, but only on short-haul flights.

Alt-right members say they were 'fooled by Trump after disavowal
Trump denounced the group in an hour-long sit-down interview with The New York Times at the newspaper's Manhattan headquarters. White Nationalists gathered on Saturday to celebrate the Donald Trump presidency as a victory for white Americans.

NZ on brink of victory at lunch
But the way that four seamers got into spells and held their areas for long periods at a time, it was world-class. Azhar added Misbah would be a big loss for his side, if he did not make it back in time for the match.

Deere is surging after crushing earnings in a farming recession (DE)
US farmer incomes are projected to fall to the lowest level in seven years as consecutive bumper crops have tempered prices. Also, Deere did close just over $5.0 billion in sales, which stands to help the financing side of the business.

No. 16 Wisconsin beats Georgetown 73-57 in Maui semifinals
Pryor carried the Hoyas on Monday as only two Georgetown players finished with double-digit point totals. The second half saw both teams begin to struggle from the free throw line.

Duterte to Declare Disputed Area a No-Fishing Zone for All
He called the move to create a marine sanctuary there "the highest form of aquaculture preservation". He said there were six boats from the Chinese Coastguard in the shoal but they were not shooed away.

North Carolina's Governor Won't Concede Without A Fight
While the McCrory campaign's false accusations have been rejected, Roy Cooper's lead has grown to almost 8,000 votes. Their rulings could still be appealed to the state board, whose members are appointed by the governor.

Android Nougat is Rolling Out to the LG G5 on Sprint
Other devices whose Android Nougat update is also under development are Samsung Galaxy S6 and S6 Edge. The update brings in November's security patch as well, which is the latest patch from Google.

Flacco, Ravens keep Browns winless with 28-7 rout
On the Ravens' next possession, Breshad Perriman caught his first career touchdown pass on a 27-yarder from Flacco. Flacco connected with five receivers on the drive, closing with a 4-yard touchdown pass to Darren Waller.

Chelsea returns to top of Premier League after narrow win over Middlesbrough
He wants to continue his excellent form, while making sure that Chelsea remain the team to beat in the English top-flight. Chelsea just didn't look right, and facing two sides they were supposed to be challenging, they were bossed.

Trump rally carries stocks to new records
Benchmark United States crude was up $1.65, to $47.34 a barrel, while Brent crude, the worldwide standard, rose $1.73, to $48.59. The company also said CEO Donnie Smith will step down at the end of this year, and company president Tom Hayes will replace him.

Conway Says Trump's Cooled On His Campaign Promise To Investigate Clinton
In today's Tea Party and post-truth environments, it is going to be hard to replace the Electoral College with a national vote. Since 1988, Wisconsin has been a Democratic state , casting all of its electoral votes toward the Democratic candidate.

Longer study needed on Zika's impact on men's fertility, World Health Organization says
The formal designation had helped the agency compel countries to report data on Zika cases within their borders. Zika and microcephaly will surface wherever there are vectors that can transmit the disease, the experts said.

Are Bayern Munich really in danger of not winning the Bundesliga?
Tensions flared with five minutes to go as Franck Ribery clashed with Adrian Ramos, and Renato Sanches was shown a yellow card. But RB Leipzig are top, three points clear of the mighty Bayern, after their thrilling 3-2 win at Bayer Leverkusen on Friday.

WWE 'Survivor Series' 2016 results: Match winners, reaction & highlights
However, it is still weird that they chose Shane McMahon to replace Baron Corbin as the fifth member of their team . The WWE Survivor Series 2016 matches are scheduled for the date November 20 at the Air Canada Centre in Toronto.

Other news